Every so often, Frank Warren posts questions he was lucky enough to get to ask his father.
Since I got so used to answering for Mom on the phone and in the hospital, I’m going to use the questions to see what I can shake out of my memory about her.
25 “Dad” Questions by Frank Warren
Do you have a favorite snack, song, television show, recipe, comedy?
Snack — She loved a good muffuletta from Renzo’s, tempura cauliflower from Ganzo or Ramen Lab Eatery, buffalo cauliflower (with marinara) from Renzo’s. Cabot sharp cheddar cheese. Gherkins. She loved to graze rather than have meals.
Song — “I Can See You,” Taylor Swift. “Roll Out,” Ludacris. “Something Sexy About the Rain,” Kenny Chesney
TV Show — If it was on Bravo or TLC, it was on in our house.
Recipe — Her enchilada chicken and “Whore Sauce” were my favorites. No one made a better burger. Grammy used to say “Pumpkin makes everything better.”
Comedy — My grandmother loved Gallagher and George Carlin. Mom and I always made our own dumb jokes. I don’t really remember Mom caring about comics or comedies. We loved dramas and romance movies.
Can you tell me about your best friend when you were a kid and one of your adventures?
She and Sherry had been friends since middle school, I think.
When Mom was pregnant with me, she was dating a few people but knew my idiot father was Tom. There was a “DK” and a Gabor in her orbit.
Gabor was fabulous and gay. I looked him up and he lives nearby. DK — Donnie — I got named after.
Anyway when she was pregnant with me, someone called her up and played The Eagles’ “Lyin’ Eyes” on the phone. She was convinced for 40 years that Sherry and their other idiot friend Debbie did it, not DK and his people.
OK maybe this was to solicit a good adventure but that’s all I got.
I do know she was close to her cousins Val and Dana. Uncle Joe and Aunt Claudia’s kids. I don’t remember much offhand except we loved Dana’s first husband Ronnie. When they divorced, we stopped believing in true love. If they couldn’t make it, no one could.
Can you describe a favorite memory about a family member?
Hmm, one of her favorite memories about a family member?
She loved her Uncle Tom, Grampy’s brother from Lancaster.
Uncle Tom always came over smelling like expensive cologne. Always handed her a $50 every time he saw her.
When she died, I found a bunch of $50s in cards from him to her.
I remember when he died. Mom and I were in the car on the way home from Port St. Lucie. Elaine called and Mom’s soul just broke in two.
I looked over at her and saw cows grazing on the side of I-95. I’ll never forget that drive or the spot where we were when we heard the news.
My Gram was best friends with his wife Mary. Mary went on to marry another Tom.
Mary and Gram always cooked together and were total besties. Gram hated anyone who had (my last name) by blood but was totally cool with those who married into the family.
What is the oldest story you know about our ancestors?
Mom’s dad Calvin loved his momma Jessie. Or Jesse. No one is really sure how she spelled it. She was French, is all I know.
I looked up Jessie a few years back. She had divorced Grampy’s dad and married a guy named Hugh G. Dick. This is not a typo or a joke.
Jessie’s obituary caught my eye. It was not my last name or Hugh’s but, rather, her maiden name Davis on her headstone.
I sent a pic of Jessie to my cousin Meg. She said oh wow you look like her.
I never knew Jessie. Honestly I always thought I looked like a combo of my mother and maternal grandmother. Who knew I also looked like my paternal grandmother, too?
But the oldest story I have is about my maternal great-grandparents.
Again, not a great one. Those are unfortunately the stories that stuck with me.
Anyway, my great-grandmother Anastasia lived with us. Anna Banana.
She was divorced from Joseph Sr.
She never said he was an abusive piece of shit but the stories led to that.
She was excommunicated from the Catholic church for divorcing him and not promising she wouldn’t remarry. (She didn’t remarry.)
Joseph Sr. beat the shit out of their son, Joseph Jr., when their dog sneezed and he said, “Bless you.”
And their son Vincent died as a baby.
Uncle Joe worked on the railroad and left his fortune to his second wife, Barbie. I fucking hated her. Loved his first wife Claudia, her daughter Val and my first cousin (once removed? I really don’t get this shit) Kara.
Something stupid happened when I was 10 that the family became less close. The Thing happened directly to me. It caused me lifelong annoyance but I never blamed anyone for it. Let’s just say it’s been character building.
Anyway, I don’t really affiliate with anyone blood-related these days other than Val, Kara and Meg.
Everyone good is dead and the rest (minus those three, plus Bobby, John, Brenna, Kylie and Riley) might as well be.
Is there something about me that you have always wanted to know but have never asked?
So if I read this right, this is Frank asking his Dad if he had any questions about him.
Would Mom have had any questions about me that she couldn’t answer? I don’t know.
I do know my cousin Carole was very concerned when I was spending a lot of time traveling with Laura. Carole was convinced that something was going on there.
Uhh … she was a travel writer who got paid to travel and eat, and Laura took me along for the ride for a couple years?!
Mom and Carole had a fraught history. So Mom quit talking to her and cited that as the last straw. But there was a whole straw factory behind it.
Still, I would guess Mom always did wonder if that was something I might be interested in.
Not Laura (def not — we were just travel buddies).
That said, I don’t think I hid the Melissa of it all very well.
In any event, I do wonder if Mom had any inkling that I crashed my car coming home from the hospital in Miami one night.
I showed up in a Mustang next hospital visit (and I also lost my job at the same time).
And I KNOW she wondered. But she was so messed up from the cancer and the surgery and the terrible hospital experience that she couldn’t find the words to ask.
I miss that Mustang but I miss her more.
Mustangs are easy to come by. Good mothers are not.
Just look on BlueSky for evidence.
If this was to be our very last conversation, is there anything you would want to say to me?
Well ouch. I asked Mom so many times to leave me one voicemail. Just one. Just a hello or something, knowing the last conversation was coming.
I never got that voicemail.
Is there anything I want to say to her? I mean, in death I do.
I was never a hugger or a love bug or anything she wanted or needed me to be.
But in life, even in the end, I was just my annoyed and annoying self.
I loved Cocoa out, in her words.
I like to think I loved her out, too.
(One thing I just realized is she wasn’t with her parents when they died. They died alone. I was with my mom and all three of my cats who’ve passed. I got to see that last breath. It’s so sad and yet so beautiful to know they felt safe enough to go because I was there.)
Now THAT said …
Between cleaning up all the black vomit and all the laundry I did and all the trash I had to run downstairs because the chute was broken, I was operating at peak asshole levels.
So yeah, I’d say I am sorry you never got to help me pick out a wedding dress and do all the “normal” things good moms should have the chance to do.
Not sorry, however, I didn’t end up with a loser just to give her those experiences.
She was hopeful for Mike L. But the L stood for loser, just like all the rest. I think she just wanted me with a guy who was equally hot and kind. Me, too, Momma. Me, too.
What is your first memory?
I know Gram used to bop her with a hairbrush when she did her hair.
Gram was just strong — she would give me head massages with her nails and it was intense. Elaine and her half-sister Lisa loved Gram’s back scratches. But mom did NOT like getting bopped with the hairbrush.
I also know Grampy took Mom and one of her friends (either Sherry or her cousin Val) to see Bobby Sherman in concert.
Grampy took a clipboard and pretended to work for him. And he got Mom in to meet him.
Bobby Sherman. I gotta look him up. If I still read Cindy, I’m sure she’ll have 47 tweets about how she knew him before Mom did. And since she’s older than Mom, she probably knew Sky Daddy when he was a boy, too.
I really don’t know a lot about her childhood since we really grew up together. A lot of my firsts were hers, too. And I was the adventurous one — I took her on all my expeditions, whenever I could. So at least the memories were shared.
Did you ever get into trouble as a kid? What happened?
Other than getting pregnant a week before her 16th birthday, not much.
I know she didn’t tell anyone about me. Then at about six months, Gram and Old Gram were commenting on how skinny she looked.
Old Gram had wisely predicted, “The fall before the rise.”
And … not long after, her belly popped and she couldn’t hide it anymore.
If there was a biography of you, how would you want to be described?
I don’t think she’d want a biography. She always felt awful that she was a “freeloader” in my house.
Sometimes she’d text and say, “It’s your worthless mother.” But then we met a worthless mother or two and she quit saying that.
I do think “Harper Valley PTA” would have to be the lead song on the soundtrack. She dressed me in frilly little dresses as a kid. And she’d get called to school because my skirts were too short.
So she’d pick me up instead of bringing a change of clothes. We’d go to lunch a lot. I wonder if she dressed me like that so she’d have a reason to take me to Chi-Chi’s instead of leaving me there to rot.
Chi-Chi’s closed years ago, but is making a comeback.
I invested in its Reg-CF offering. I never invested so much in my life.
I know it won’t bring Momma back, but if it brings Chi-Chi’s back, it’s worthwhile because she LOVED it there.
What choice are you thankful that you did not make?
Roe v. Wade went into effect around the time I was conceived. I often asked why she didn’t just do it.
She always said I was the best thing she ever did.
Sometimes I joked I was the only thing she ever did. Because she really was born to be a mom. She loved me, and motherhood, and all that came with it.
Even when I was a shit, from ages zero to 50, she loved it all. Or at least didn’t let it show that it might not have.
She would have never sat on social media and complained like some people do.
What is the best advice you remember from your father?
Grampy thought she hung the moon. She was his princess. His punkin.
I will have to think about any advice he might have given her.
I know when (my) Juddy didn’t get Homecoming King, Grampy wrote him a beautiful poem about how these big disappointments will fade away when the big victories come our way.
He was right about that.
I think the fact that my grandparents — who lived in a 2BR row house/Section 8 with my great grandmother, mom, cousin Carole, Carole’s daughter Robyn (named after my mom) — welcomed the news of me speaks volumes.
Mom always said they loved me more than they did her. I was their chance to get the parent thing right.
Not that they were bad but she said the love was SO different for me.
And I somehow made them love HER more, for giving me to them to help raise.
She took care of them their whole lives. We really all were so close.
It hurts more to lose people like that, who loved you so unconditionally.
On the upside, there was nothing unresolved. We all knew we loved each other.
The only sad part is that they had more love to give but their bodies just wouldn’t let them.
Is there anything you wish you had said to someone but didn’t have the chance?
Gram used to say Mom wouldn’t say shit even if she had a mouth full.
Gram would read you to fucking filth. She would have eviscerated Cindy and every boss I ever had. Everyone in the family got told who and what they were.
In time, I learned she was right about them all.
I think Mom would have told more people off instead of accepting it. She sure fucking told off anyone who ever dared to mess with me.
But when it came to her? She was like well fuck you then and wouldn’t “lick dick,” as my grandmother would say.
That said, I regret all the time we wasted on laughing at Cindy.
I mean, she gave us so much material. Plus, Mom encouraged me to see what her mentally ill ass was up to, in case she was dumb enough to telegraph that she was going to hurt me. (She IS dumb enough.)
When Mom was at her sickest, I did stop reading. I didn’t have the bandwidth.
And I can predict with more certainty than a pregnancy test that she’s making fun of me for hurting that I lost my mom. So who wants to read that shit anyway?
Anyway, I would love all that time and mental bandwidth back that we wasted on losers.
Can you teach me something?
Momma taught me everything I know.
She didn’t want to leave because she said she had so much to teach me still.
Now, exactly one year after I lost her, she taught me that I can somehow survive the worst possible hurt I could ever have imagined.
I would rather have learned how to get a good man and what kind of wedding dress would work with my figure and where to honeymoon.
What is something you would like me to ask you?
Probably how she felt after I said something stupid or hurtful.
We always laughed things off. Never really just said man that was terrible and I am sorry. As soon as we had food, the slate was wiped clean again.
What do you wish you would have spent less time worrying about?
Everything! I couldn’t microwave her food or put “too much” deodorant on her because, cancer.
Jesus Christ the shit was in her bones and every organ. A swipe of deodorant or a goddamned cup of hot tea was not going to be what killed her.
She also worried what people thought. Got up and dressed and hair fixed every day. Even with Stage 4 cancer.
Like, you don’t have to be a wreck of the Hesperus like you know who.
But you don’t have to draw on your eyebrows to sit in the car while I run errands, either.
What is something you deliberately did not tell me as a child and why?
She told me just about everything. And the rest, I guessed.
I would guarantee my stepfather was as abusive as my maternal grandfather.
I knew something was wrong with his ass in 1977, when they were about to elope and I begged her not to. I was 3.
My family never doubted that kids know everything and that spirits talk to children. How the hell else would I have known to say that?
What is the best part of your day? What makes you feel most alive?
Hanging out with me. Going shopping. Picking out outfits for me. Sharing a piece of cheesecake with Kadie. Giving all her “ribbies” to Cocoa. Sneaking treats to Magic. Hugging Bella, the forgotten middle child. Collecting memes and pretty pictures to paste to Facebook as collages.
Simple things.
She was always amazed at our weekends away. I always wanted her to have something to look forward to. We would eat good food and shop in new stores. She loved that.
So when Wildebeest would say shit about shallow shopaholics, I would want to transfer Mom’s cancer over there.
Fuck it, I still do. Especially when my friend who still reads that trainwreck reports back with whatever lie she’s posted about me lately.
What is the last thing you changed your mind about?
Hospice. She didn’t want me to call those incompetents but in the end she asked why I didn’t call.
Of course then I did call and as she was passing, the night nurse was stuck at the gate.
So I barely got to be with her for her last breath at 2:47 a.m. (and the light went out in her eyes at 2:49) before I had to run down and fuck with the stupid gate at 3:10.

She was pronounced at 3:26.
What things helped you get through a difficult time in your life?
Jimmy. And T-Bird Jimmy. And Randy. And Randi. Jesus how did these names keep recurring.
Oh then there was Blob. Sherry texted that he died last month. I hope Momma stays far away from him. Of course, he’s probably in hell so I am not going to worry.
The most difficult time of her life was when Grampy died. I gave up my 1BR and got us a 2BR. And Blob moved her to Maryland (and stole whatever shit of ours she didn’t have in her purse).
That was the worst. I was so angry at the world. But I understand it now. At some point, you really do just need to rest after going through hell.
I wanted her to fight. Now I see I had enough fight in me for both of us.
And I shouldn’t have wasted it trying to fight with her to be more independent at that time.
Over the course of your life what trip or place was most special? Why?
There was one “family trip” — I took Mom, Cocoa, Bella and Magic to Islamorada. All five of us. We stayed in a room that walked out to the ocean.
She had a walker by that time and didn’t go too far onto the sand. But she loved sitting on the lanai and having cocktails with me.
Best trip ever. Only one we got as a family of five.
What would you like to re-experience again because you did not appreciate it enough the first time?
She was a pretty happy person. I would think anything that involved good food. A nice night at Delmonico. Stuffed shrimp at Island Fish Co. in Islamorada. A fried fish sandwich at Skyview or Reenie’s back in Pittsburgh. A Jim’s hot dog in Dravosburg.
On second thought, the last time my grandfather played guitar lived rent-free in our minds.
He hadn’t played in forever. But she got him a cord for his amplifier and he busted out “Me and Bobby McGhee.”
We cried. We literally sat there and sobbed. It was wonderful.
I wish with all my might we had smartphones then, in 2006. I would have recorded that and played the shit out of it for the past 20 years.
Cousin Bobby has that amp now. I forget what happened to Grampy’s songbook. Someone wanted it. I hope it was Bobby but I really don’t know.
Can you tell me something about yourself that I don’t know that you think would surprise, shock or delight me?
I was always surprised and delighted by my momma. She would sing that Christmas song her way: “Oh the fire’s so fucking frightful. And your momma’s so fucking delightful.”
I remember when she was little, she saw a horse with a big dick and asked Grampy about it. He told her the horse was “sitting on a stick.” Hah.
He didn’t like to talk about sex. We always said his nose would wiggle off his face.
It’s so true — anytime he was uncomfortable, his nose would wiggle.
What habits served you the most through life?
She was psychic but about dumb stuff. So am I. Life decisions, no luck. But knowing what route to take to avoid traffic? We’re your girls.
She never developed her gift and was so proud that I have a coven and take classes regularly to communicate with the spirit guides and the dead.
What is the best mistake you have made, and why?
Becoming a mom. See above. I brought the family closer together. And her parents were AMAZING about having me in our little Section 8 townhouse. They scraped together some money and got us a nice rental house in a nice part of town. Truly I had an amazing childhood because of these angels.
What do you hope my siblings and I have learned from you?
Mom tried so hard to soften me. I was always kind of a hardass. I don’t care about hugs so much. Or romance or anything like that. I just always wanted to work or be left alone.
She really did make me more compassionate. But as i fought with doctors and hospitals and loser boyfriends, she remarked that all she’d done to soften me was being undone by incompetence and insensitivity.
She wasn’t wrong. I was seeing someone recently and I told him, “You are competing with my peace.” And my peace, ultimately, won.
How are you doing right now? Is there anything on your mind right now that you’d like to talk about?
Considering she’s been dead for one year, I will skip this one.
I do talk to her a lot. And I have about four million signs she’s around me.
Like, the fact that my hotel room this weekend was 616 — she died on 6/16.

Or the fact that I accidentally tried to get into 619 — Grampy’s favorite number.
Or that a moth sat next to me at the hotel pool for 35 minutes while I talked to him about her.
I knew the one-year mark would cement for me that she was gone.
I really did get the feeling that the little moth friend I made was telling me, just like her last words on earth, “I gotta go.”
She hung out with me in spirit for a year. Now it’s time to find and use her wings.
I truly believe that. I hope I get to ask someday if I was right.
Love you so much, Momma. I know I cry more for Cocoa. But I got more time with you. Though you were both equally dependent on me.
I hope I didn’t fuck up too much. I also don’t know what to do with all this love I had for you guys.
Maybe you can throw me a sign sometime about that.